Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
You Need To Make This Mac and Cheese Today!
You Need To Make This Mac and Cheese Today!

You Need To Make This Mac and Cheese Today!

  • Updated
  • 0

Sharp Cheddar Mac n Cheese

I scream, you scream for Mac n Cheese? Well… maybe that isn’t the saying, but this mac n cheese will have your taste buds screaming for more once you try it. Our contributor Sarah Garrison stands by this hearty recipe and says it is a crowd pleaser every time she makes it. Combining tried and true ingredients of flour, butter, and milk with the sharpest cheddar you can find will make this recipe a go to for every time someone says “bring some mac n cheese”. For a little added boost of flavor try throwing the recipe in the smoker instead of the oven.

Let’s dig in!

Sharp Cheddar Mac n Cheese

You will need the following ingredients:

6 tbsp butter or margarine

6 tbsp flour

2 cups of milk

4 cups grated sharp cheddar cheese (we found Extra Sharp Tillamook works best, get yours here!)

3 cups macaroni (we found this is best with penne, shells work also, but if you go elbow go big!)

Let’s get to cookin’:

Step 1: Cook you pasta to al dente. Straining your pasta is a breeze with this over the sink strainer/colander. Also go ahead and preheat the oven to 350 degrees


Step 2: Let’s make some cheese sauce! Melt your butter and add flour, whisking until smooth. The Balloon Whisk by Zulay Kitchen is great for this step! Once smooth gradually add milk while whisking. Cook over medium heat until mixture has thickened. Lastly slowly add your cheese and continue to stir until melted.

Step 3: Time to combine and create deliciousness! Combine your amazing cheese sauce with that cooked pasta and transfer to a 2 quart baking dish. This model from Pyrex is fantastic, it even has a lid making travel a breeze! Sprinkle with some paprika (smoked and Spanish paprika your excellent options as well)

Step 4: This is the hardest part. The wait. We now have to bake this amazing creation for 45 minutes at 350 degrees. Now here is where you could also get some smoke (recommend a pecan or apple wood) on this mac and cheese and really boost the flavor! Bake as directed except remove at the 35 minute mark and place your mac n cheese in the smoker at 275 for about 30 minutes (roughly). Checking for doneness every 15 minutes until done.

Let’s eat! Pair this dish with brats, ribs, pulled pork, chicken, brisket, you name it. Also does fantastic as a stand-alone dish and can be infused with broccoli or a meat of your choice. Maybe lobster?

We hope you enjoy the products we recommend. We may receive a commission if you purchase a product mentioned in this article.


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Your dog is family, so it's only natural to want to enjoy his company all the time, and take him along everywhere possible. However, the decision to travel with a pet - particularly on an extended road trip - is one that requires a good deal of consideration. There are several questions you should ask yourself before loading Rover up in the car, and all of them involve ensuring your pet's ultimate comfort and well-being.

  • Updated

The joy of shouting to your friends over the roar of a crowded bar, the giddiness of seeing the world rushing by below you from the seat of an airplane, the weirdly constricting sensation of wearing pants that aren’t elastic — the summer of 2021 brought back many experiences we had forgone during the past year and a half of the pandemic.

  • Updated

A small amount of bleach can typically be diluted in water and poured down the sink. For larger amounts, check if there are any disposal instructions printed on the container. If not, call your local hazardous-waste-disposal facility for their recommendations.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News